|
Page 2 of 2
From a discussion on Shadowplay - The willfully eccentric film blog of David Cairns
A mystery Shadowplayer, who wishes to remain anomalous, dropped in to add some thoughts to the mythic storytelling discussion. We’d been discussing stuff like Joseph Campbell’s The Hero With A Thousand Faces and Propp’s Morphology of the Folk tale.
‘Part of the problem is that both Campbell and Propp have what seem to
me v. mechanical understandings of myth (tho the latter is sort of
interesting til one gets his point, which happens pretty quick).
Compare that to the understandings of Roberto Calasso (who you shd read), Joyce, Rilke… Jung is more interesting than Campbell and Eliade maybe more interesting still. Victoria Nelson’s Secret Life of Puppets is a plenty intriguing modern study.’I was promoted to reply, thinking of Campbell: ‘Listing the most common
features of world mythology is sort of interesting but does that mean
we SHOULDN’T take inspiration from less popular myths? George Lucas
would presumably say YES.’
The Mystery Man shot back:
‘Not only that, but the Propp/Campbell (and to a lesser extent Jungian)
models all focus on similarities and neglect or shave off difference.
Whereas someone like Calasso, in his retellings, makes the crucial
point that myths EXIST in their variants, their sum-total of tellings,
and resist any “definitive” form. So laying them down on a structural
grid, and cutting to fit the pattern, may have some interest, but it’s
also a considerable violence.’
Me: And again, it CAN have a rather deleterious effect on the imaginations of those seeking a “mythic model.”
Him:‘It has a “deleterious effect” on EVERYONE.’
The Pearson-Marr Archetype Indicator® is an online self-test that can unveil
the unconscious patterns that shape your life.
Sergio Leone and the Western Myth: Reading the Ritual - brilliantly insightful Austin Fisher dissertation on Leone.
Westerns Ride Off Into the Sunset - western films - Brief Article
USA Today (Society for the Advancement of Education)
The Hero's Journey is an archetypal path of individual transformation. It is a map that shows the stages of our personal process of evolution. These stages are revealed time and again in myths and legends in all cultures throughout the history of humanity. While the structure of these stages is universal, the expression is completely unique for each individual.
|